The "normal" location of the 928's temperature gauge causes a lot of angst
among owners, and not just on this list. I think that it's fair to say that the
928's temperature gauge is inaccurate, but individual gauges usually are
consistent.
Based on five years participating in online 928 forums, my observation is that
the "normal" position for a gauge usually is anywhere between the two large
white marks. Obviously, you should satisfy yourself that the engine is not
overheating; otherwise, you should take note when your temp needle moves from
ITS normal position, wherever that may be. NEVER ignore the temp warning light!
The indicated temperature will rise on hot days in heavy (ie slow) traffic, when
you are going hard on the track and if you're going exceptionally hard on the
road. My gauge usually sits at the lower white mark, including at high speed,
with the aircon on, in ambient temps of over 105F.
As Doug says, the standard 928 has heaps of cooling capacity (not forgetting
those 8 liters of oil). If the temp of the thermostat housing is usually in the
85-90 degrees C (185-195F) range, it is right where Porsche intended it to be,
so you shouldn't worry, let alone mess with the cooling system to make you feel
better about the gauge reading.
Glenn Evans
'80 Petrolblaumetallic 'S' look
5 speed
Sydney, Oz
============
Hi Bora,
we all know how inaccurate the 928's "living" temperature indicator
(gauge) is however this may interest you
For the last nearly two years I have monitored my car's temperatures at various
locations using an IR temp. reader which has an accuracy of about +/-2C.
Ambient: Lowest -5C Highest 43C
avg | min | max | median | remark | |
Gauge | 85 | 81 | 87 | 85 | reads about midway mostly |
Thermo housing | 86 | 78 | 90 | 86 | |
Rad hose top | 72 | 55 | 88 | 74 | |
Rad hose lower | 76 | 61 | 90 | 76 | |
Valve covers | 88 | 85 | 94 | 88 | |
Vee near sender | 88 | 80 | 94 | 88 | |
Oil cooler top | 74 | 54 | 88 | 75 | |
Oil cooler lower | 76 | 53 | 90 | 77 | |
ATF cooler top | 60 | 43 | 76 | 61 | |
ATF cooler lower | 50 | 31 | 77 | 51 | |
These figures are the product of nearly 100 IR readings taken over nearly
30000kms and all were taken after a minimum of 50kms had been covered Note that
in nearly all cases the average and median are very close suggesting excellent
stability within the cooling system
In a well maintained 928 and using a 83C(OEM) thermostat (these open at 83C and
are fully open at 98C)it appears that the engine's "core" temperature hovers
around the 85>90C mark under most conditions.
People using a 75C thermostat in "normal" use should note the Valve Cover and
Vee results above. Lowering these by 8C (75C against 83C) may cause excessive
wear in cold ambient temperatures with very little (if any) gain in high
temperature operation
The 928 has enormous cooling system capacity when viewed as a system (coolant,
oil and air). It certainly needs air flow!
The S4's first overheat warning is at 118C and the "final" warning is at 120C
Oil temperatures are always hard to obtain accurately but when using the correct
viscosity synthetic oil up to 130C is not a problem In normal use and going by
my readings I think the 928's engine oil hovers around the 85C (the oil cooler
thermostat opens at 87C)to 100C range, this is absolutely ideal for long oil and
engine life
My vehicle is NOT operated in a City environment very often, however I do live
in Tropical Australia
I hope this helps in understanding our cars a little better
Regards
Doug Hillary
===========
Hi,
yes Chris the only published oil pressure (OP) by Porsche for the 928 that I am
aware of is given as a minimum of 5bar at 4000-5000rpm and with the oil
(obviously the recommended viscosity) at between 80C-100C
This minimum of 5bar does not tell the true story either. As the oil pressure
relief valve opens at 8-9bar (variously) it is possible that using thicker oils
may trip the relief valve at higher revs (and also the filter by-pass valve)
even in normal day to day use!
It is possible that the actual oil pressure may well indeed be above 5bar and
near 6 or 7bar for a lot of the time when using SAE50 oils (say
15w-50)
Low idle OP is really only a worry if it triggers the switch. Always check that
the warning light works during start up Very few engine makers (if any) specify
an idle OP (see below) minimum any longer - they simply and reliably rely on the
sender and light working.
At idle too many variables may apply and the dashboard indicator (gauge) is just
that - an indicator. In the 928 of course we have a gauge and a light!
Many years ago (40 or so) MB had the following idle oil pressure requirement for
one engine family as follows;
1 - Use a calibrated "Master Gauge"
2 - Oil = SAE10w
3 - Oil Temperature = 100C
4 - Required idle oil pressure = >2bar
Note: At 2500rpm using 1 to 3)above oil pressure= 5bar
So strict controls were applied even then as the idle OP is a difficult
parameter to reliably replicate
Many people get confused about OP and perhaps forget that the flow is extremely
significant. The oil pump is of constant displacement (it delivers the same
amount for every revolution). At idle some circulation losses do occur but the
flow of a conforming viscosity lubricant when hot will still leave the pump in
the same volume! You may see a lower pressure with thinner conforming oils but
remember that the flow (volume) is constant per rev.!
As long as you meet the Porsche specification of 5bar at 4000-5000rpm and the
(working) oil pressure light does not illuminate you are meeting Porsche's
design intent!
The flow v pressure issue is misunderstood by many - and has been for decades. A
more linear flow (as with a viscosity conforming synthetic) does increase the
oil's ability to carry away heat and there is less likelihood of opening the
pressure relief valve
High OPs are NOT always a good thing - the maker's correct pressures are!
Very high OPs, cold thick oil and high revs. are indeed a good recipe for
damaging engine bearings. This is due to the hydrodynamic "wedge" affect in this
individual area of engine lubrication. In these circumstances too of course the
oil will be likely flowing back to the pump via the relief valve and by-passing
the oil filter
As Mark is very well aware, racing a 928 represents another scenario altogether
- this post does not cover that situation!
I hope this is of some interest
Regards
Doug